Download Menus
Gary’s Favorites
Available Gluten-Free Friendly
*prices and availability subject to change.
Gary’s Favorites
Gluten-Free Friendly
NEW! Columbus Daily Specials
MONDAY: Fried Shrimp Dinner
$19.99
panko-breaded fried shrimp, french fries, coleslaw, tartar sauce, cocktail sauce
TUESDAY: Taco Salad
$16.29
seasoned ground beef or chicken, cheddar cheese, refried beans, iceberg lettuce mix, jalapeno, pico de gallo, scallion, toasted flour tortilla, cilantro ranch
WEDNESDAY: Indiana Pork Tenderloin
$14.99
beer-battered golden-fried pork tenderloin, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, brioche bun, side of mayonnaise, french fries
THURSDAY: Italian Torpedo Sandwich
$15.49
salami, tavern ham, spicy italian sausage, lettuce, tomato, onion, pepperoncini, mayo, balsamic dressing, Bay City hoagie roll, french fries
FRIDAY: Shrimp Scampi
$21.99
sauteed shrimp, white wine garlic sauce, roasted tomato, herb compound butter, parmesan, spaghetti, garlic bread
SATURDAY: Coney Dogs
$16.99
two all-beef hot dogs topped with sirloin chili, shredded cheddar cheese, Dijon mustard, side of diced white onion, french fries
SUNDAY: Kentucky Hot Brown
$16.99
oven roasted turkey, bacon, tomato, toasted brioche, parmesan mornay sauce, scallions
Start Here
Chicken Fingers
$13.49
pilsner-battered, crispy fries
Cheese Blanket Nachos
$13.99
seasoned ground beef or chicken, corn tortilla chips, cheese for days, braised black beans, jalapeño, pico de gallo, sour cream, scallions
*available for dine-in only
Brussels Sprouts
$10.49
cabbage patch kids
parmesan, lemon aioli
Peel & Eat Shrimp
$12.99
chilled, old bay, crab louis, cocktail sauce
Fried Pickles
$10.79
pilsner-battered spears, cilantro ranch
Spinach Con Queso
$10.49
liquid gold, chardonnay, spinach, tomato, corn chips
Double Stacked Quesadilla
$12.79
blackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean & corn salsa
Wings
$14.29
Sauces: joe’s regular, BBQ or habanero, blue cheese, celery
Soup 'R' Salads
Caesar
$7.99
roma crunch, crouton, parmesan
Simple
carrot, cucumber, tomato, sharp cheddar, crouton,
choice of dressing
BBQ Chopped Chicken Salad
$13.79
Chop it like it's hot
BBQ glazed chicken, greens, black bean & corn salsa, tomato, pepper jack, tortilla, cilantro ranch
Blackened Salmon
$15.99
shaved fennel and brussels sprouts, mixed greens, strawberries, avocado, goat cheese, candied pecans, honey vinaigrette
Cobb
$14.79
roma crunch, bacon, avocado, egg, cucumber, marinated grape tomato, blue cheese, herbed chicken, red wine vinaigrette
Double Nickel
$7.49
bacon, tomato, onion, blue cheese crumbles, house dressing add chicken 8 or salmon 12
Trio
$14.99
choice of side salad, cup of soup & ½ club sandwich
Duo
$13.99
choice of side salad & cup of soup
Crock Of Soup
$6.99
sirloin chili | french onion | soup du jour
Kids
Just for Kiddos (10 & Under). Includes one side and choice of drink.
Kids’ Mac n Cheese
$6.29
...seriously? we need to explain?
Chocolate Cake
$5.99
Kids’ Sides
french fries, mashed potatoes, sticky rice, broccoli, fresh fruit cup or cole slaw
Kids’ Spaghetti
$7.49
with garlic bread
Kids’ Chicken Fingers
$6.99
BBQ or honey mustard
Kids’ Cheese Pizza
$7.49
Kids’ Pepperoni Pizza
$7.49
Kids’ Pizza
$6.99
pepperoni or cheese
Kids’ Soft Tacos
$7.29
taco meat, lettuce, cheese ...not just for Tuesdays!
Kids’ Sliders
$7.49
...with or without cheese
Kids’ Trip to Disneyland
... priceless
Tavern Food With Attitude
3-Way
$15.99
a cincinnati classic! buttered spaghetti, sirloin chili,
sharp cheddar, tomato, white onion, sour cream,
scallion
Double Stacked Quesadilla
$16.99
blackened chicken, cheddar, pepper jack, black bean & corn salsa, side of mexican street corn salad
Chicken Fingers
$17.49
pilsner-battered, coleslaw, seasoned fries
Beef Stroganoff
pot roast, wild mushroom cream, scallions, sour cream
Chicken Parmesan
panko-crusted, tomato ragout, alfredo noodles
Soy Glazed Salmon
sticky rice, stir-fried beans, toasted sesame seeds
Ma, The Meatloaf!
ma! we want it now!
green beans, mashed potatoes, wild mushroom demi glace
New York Strip
seasoned fries, roasted wild mushrooms, herb butter
add a brown bag beer for $1
Fish & Chips
pilsner-battered cold water haddock, seasoned fries, cole slaw, tartar
Baja Tacos
blackened mahi, pico de gallo, cabbage, avocado lime crema, mexican street corn salad
Best Flippin' Burgers
served with kettle chips, cole slaw or fries. Substitute onion rings, sweet potato fries, or mac & cheese for an additional $1.99.
100% whole wheat bun available upon request.
Sliders
$15.49
caramelized onion, american cheese, pickle chips, brioche buns
Bacon
ground bacon and beef, sharp cheddar, more bacon, caramelized onion, lettuce, tomato, roasted garlic aioli
The Imposter
plant based, mayo, sweet pickle relish, LTO, dill pickle chips, american cheese
make it vegan and dump the dairy
(request no mayo or cheese)
Turkey
american cheese, mayo, pickle, LTO
Bucket
the O.G.
american, mayo, sweet pickle relish, LTO, dill pickle chips
Hold Me Now
Sandwiches served with your choice of kettle chips, coleslaw or fries. Substitute onion rings, sweet potato fries, or mac & cheese for an additional $1.99.
100% whole wheat bun available upon request.
Fish Sandwich
pilsner-battered haddock, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo, onion, tartar
Club Sandwich
turkey, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, wheat bread
Cheesesteak
peppers, onion, mushroom, provolone, philly sauce
Reuben
slow-braised corned beef brisket, swiss, thousand, kraut, artisan rye
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
g.o.a.t.
panko-crusted, blue cheese crumbles, lettuce, tomato, mayo
El Cubano
tavern ham, braised pork, swiss, house mustard, pickles
Hoosier Daddy Pork Tenderloin
No chair throwing please!
breaded and fried, lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion, side mayo
Artisan Pizza
Cheese
provolone, whole milk mozzarella
Sicilian
italian sausage, ezzo pepperoni, tavern ham, peppers, caramelized onion
Wild Mushroom
there is fungus among us
roasted garlic, shiitake, portabella, caramelized onion, spinach, truffle oil
Veggie
spinach, wild mushroom, roasted tomato, peppers, onion, green olive
Pepperoni & Peppers
ezzo pepperoni & hungarian peppers, das it
Margherita
roasted tomato, garlic, fresh mozzarella, basil
Toppings
veg: jalapeño, peppers, spinach, roasted tomato, onion, wild mushroom, green olive... $1.99 each
meat: ezzo pepperoni, sausage, bacon, tavern ham... $2.29 each
Toppings
veg: jalapeño, peppers, spinach, roasted tomato, onion, wild mushroom, green olive
meat: ezzo pepperoni, sausage, bacon, tavern ham
Toppings
veg: jalapeño, peppers, spinach, roasted tomato, onion, wild mushroom, green olive... $1.79 each
meat: ezzo pepperoni, sausage, bacon, tavern ham... $2.29 each
Sidekicks
Broccoli
Cole Slaw
$4.99
Mexican Street Corn Salad
$5.99
Mac & Cheese
Onion Rings
Fruit Cup
$4.99
Mashed Potatoes
$4.99
Sweet Potato Fries
Dessert
New York Cheesecake
macerated strawberry, whipped cream
and bonus, it’s gluten-free friendly!
Dessert Feature
check with your server to see what our chefs got cooking in their easy bake oven.
Chocolate Icebox Cake
vanilla bean ice cream & powdered sugar
Sticky Bun Bread Pudding
It will leave your taste buds saying, Oops -pow surprise! Oohhhhh!!!
baked croissants and vanilla custard, caramel, pecans, vanilla bean ice cream
Zero Proof
Raspberry Iced Tea
$5.29
Strawberry Lemonade
$5.29
Cold Brew Coffee
$5.49
brewed in-house, Kenya Windrush Estate blend
San Pellegrino
$4.49
Join us for a Happier, Happy Hour!
Weekdays 3-6 PM
1/2 Off
Apps
$12
Pizzas
$7
Juicy Lucy Burger
$1 Off
Beer, Wine, Cocktails
Join us for a Happier, Happy Hour!
Weekdays 3-6 PM
1/2 Off
Apps
$12
Pizzas
$7
Juicy Lucy Burger
Daily Drink Features
Monday Motivation
$5 wheatley vodkas all day long
to get your week started right
Poppin’ Bottles Tuesday
1/2 priced bottles of wine
Whiskey Wednesday
woodford, old forester, jack & the others
Punch Perfect Thursday
our house bucket punch on draft by the glass or pitcher
Shaken Not Stirred Friday
belvedere martini, cold brew martini, pine fin cosmo, or pine fin martini
Gary’s Famous Margarita Saturday
share a pitcher (or drink one yourself)
Bloody Sunday
pepper-infused tito's vodka, house-spiced pickle
Ask about our current barrel of Gary's Blend!
Our very own Woodford Reserve Private Selection Gary’s Blend is carefully crafted by Gary and Rusty Bucket Associates several times a year since 2011.
Available only to our Rusty Bucket guests, no two barrels are alike (just like fingerprints). It’s science. Once each barrel is gone, it’s gone. Never to be recreated. Cheers!
Dranks
If you are drinking to forget, please pay in advance
Add a 1 oz Pour for $5
A little extra Tito's never hurts!
Cold Brew Martini
$9.75
wheatley vodka, house blend cold brew coffee,
espresso vodka, cantera negra café
Bloody Mary
$10.00
pepper-soaked Tito's
Not Spicy: green, red & hungarian peppers
Spicy: jalapeño & lime
Stupid Spicy: habanero, green & red peppers
Blueberry Bella
$9.00
smirnoff blueberry, muddled blueberries, simple syrup, lemon juice
Sun Comes Up In Mexico
$11.00
cazadores reposado, cointreau, orange, lime, agave nectar, house grenadine
Bourbon and Chill
$11.00
old forester, st. germain, chamomile simple syrup, fresh lemon, mint
Draft Bucket Punch
mount gay rum, pine fin, cointreau & fresh juices, dum dum
Draft Margarita
el jimador, cointreau, fresh lemon and lime | add a bucket of herradura, el jimador, or grand marnier for $5
Pine Fin
rocks, martini, cosmo
Red Sangria
$7.75
eos cab, cointreau, lime, pom juice
Bottles & Cans
Please choose a Rusty Bucket location to see all selections.
*Available at most locations
High Noon
$6.99
Memphis, TN
Motorworks Adaptable Lager
Bradenton, FL
Coors
Golden, CO
Taft’s Nellie’s Selection
Cincinnati, OH
O’Douls
$3.99
St Louis, MO
Redbridge GF Beer
$3.99
St Louis, MO
Funky Buddha Floridian
$5.49
Oakland Park, FL
Darwin Llama Mama
$5.79
Bradenton, FL
Victory Sunny Monkey
$6.79
Downingtown, PA
Blue Blaze Brewing
$6.29
Charlotte, NC
OMB Captain Jack
$6.29
Charlotte, NC